Britain has never been more comfortable with investment. UK adults now hold £871 billion in ISAs, up from £470 billion a decade ago — the Stocks and Shares portion alone more than doubling, to £511 billion. We invest with real appetite: we accept risk and wait for the market to reward patience.
Apply that same logic to a young person’s potential, though, and Britain turns curiously risk averse. Schools confer qualifications; colleges teach skills; only an employer can create a work record, the moment an investment is finally tested, and this is where confidence fails. Employer spending on training has fallen 29.5% per employee in real terms since 2011. Britain is happy to invest in assets it can trade, but it has grown reluctant to invest in people it must first take a chance on.
The result is stark. Over a million 16- to 24-year-olds were neither earning nor learning in early 2026 — 13.5% of the cohort, 613,000 of them economically inactive rather than unemployed. Some 61.6% of NEET young people have never held a job, up from 42% in 2005.
This is not solely a failure of qualifications or motivation. The Milburn review finds entry-level roles have grown scarcer and more demanding, while recruitment has become more remote, automated and impersonal. A first job converts latent ability into competence, but the firm doing that conversion bears the training costs and the risk of an unproven hire, while every later employer inherits the benefit free of charge. The problem falls hardest, however, on those with no private credibility to borrow. Some applicants can lean on family contacts, but others cannot. Consequently, care-experienced 17- to 19-year-olds are more than twice as likely to be NEET as their peers — 26% against 11% — and the share of NEET young people inactive due to sickness or disability has more than doubled since 2005. For them, the first employer supplies proof of competence, not just income. Opportunity should not depend on who a young person already knows.
Government has begun to recognise what creating that proof costs. Launched in June 2026, the Youth Jobs Grant offers employers up to £3,000 for hiring eligible 18- to 24-year-olds: £1,800 after six weeks, and £1,200 if 300 hours appear in HMRC payroll data by eighteen weeks. But this is a poor measure of success: it only rewards hours banked with one firm, when careers are chains of employment and not single contracts.
The grant’s final instalment should be turned into a ‘First Chance Dividend’ instead. The £1,800 would remain payable at six weeks, preserving the incentive to hire. The remaining £1,200 would go to the original employer once the young person completes 26 weeks of PAYE employment within 52 weeks of first being hired, even across several firms, provided that employers gave provided at least 13 weeks and 300 hours of work and issued a reference. Consider a café that hires an untested 20-year-old who moves to a hotel four months later. The 20-year-old gains some experience, the hotel a proven recruit, the Exchequer tax receipts and lower benefit spending — but the café created much of that value, and under the current grant, forfeits recognition for it. Under the Dividend, progression would instead be encouraged and incentivised. The state’s total exposure would also remain at £3,000; DWP’s existing HMRC data feed would trigger payment automatically, so employers would also track nothing themselves.
A similar idea was tested in 2011, in South Africa. There, the Treasury considered reserving a youth subsidy proportional to the wages paid to the young person for the first registered employer, on the grounds that inexperienced workers cannot yet signal their own productivity, but it then also identified that a short first placement could exhaust a young person’s support. Australia’s Transition to Work programme likewise counts outcomes across multiple placements with different employers, as Britain’s own past employment schemes have done.
One objection is worth taking seriously. Employers may discount a delayed, uncertain £1,200 subsidy, and so it will not influence their hiring decision. This is why the immediate £1,800 remains untouched: the Dividend rewards career progression, but the hiring incentive does not depend on it alone.
Peel’s Tamworth Manifesto promised the “correction of proved abuses” alongside “the firm maintenance of established rights” — reform in service of the rights of the market, not against them. The First Chance Dividend would sit in that tradition. It is pro-enterprise, because it lowers the risk of hiring someone unproven. It is liberal, because it makes opportunity depend on effort and merit rather than inherited connections. And it is fiscally disciplined, because payment incentivise work and disincentivise sitting on welfare. Britain has learned to trust investment when the return is a share price. It should also learn to trust it when the return is a person.
Original image by Irina.
