Assisted suicide is wrong – we should re-familiarise with death

X
LinkedIn
Facebook
Adelaide Di Maggio

Adelaide Di Maggio is a Policy and Research Analyst.

Discussions on whether England and Wales should legalise assisted suicide are ongoing, with the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill currently battling through the House of Lords. Throughout the debate, a common phrase used by proponents of the Bill is that the legislation would allow people to have a ‘good’ and ‘dignified’ death. This reveals a flawed understanding of death, that to die well is to end one’s life prematurely. One of the main reasons people choose assisted suicide is to prevent a loss of control and autonomy, yet death itself is not something that can be controlled, or a solution to lack of control.

Often, we feel out of control when we do not know or understand something. And death, despite being an integral part of every person’s life, is not something many of us directly experience anymore. Much of society – perhaps except for medical professionals, healthcare staff and religious ministers – is becoming less and less familiar with death and dying. A 2023 Theos report reveals that, despite most people experiencing grief, fewer than 40% of Britons have ever witnessed someone’s death. Yet only around a century ago, the situation was different; roughly every seventh child would not survive their first year of life. Moreover, people would usually die at home, surrounded by their family and, perhaps, neighbours cherishing their last moments.

As healthcare improved, giving us a chance of better and longer lives, we have become more disconnected from death. Death does not seem to be an ordinary part of life anymore.

Many of us might never enter a care home, hospice or intensive care ward in our lives, nor witness someone dying until we reach our own end. It affects us less and we talk about it less, and, as a result, we do not know what death or dying are. We forget of its existence. We rely on books, the media, other people’s stories and sometimes a painful text message or phone call to fill this gap. And many of the deaths we read about can seem painful or tragic. This can lead to adopting distorted images of illness and the end of life; which can in turn trigger strong feelings and trauma when we encounter the prospect of real death.

Moreover, as lives get longer, as more and more products and procedures seem to be available that will help us have a healthy and fit life, and as we are able to make more choices about how we live our lives, we seem to want more choice over our deaths. This explains the call from so many people for assisted suicide or euthanasia. Just as we want to make our lives as comfortable as possible, we want to make our deaths as comfortable as possible – with an early death being brought about by medical intervention if so desired.

In this way, death becomes yet another commodity, an artificial service that we can access and choose when, how and whether we desire. Thus, we are further disengaged from the process of dying and from what it really means to have a good death.

A first step should be to become more familiar with death. There is now an unease about how death has is viewed in society. And, as we are afraid of that which we do not know, the pressure to choose assisted suicide as the escape route becomes higher.

Different religions have shared reverent outlooks toward death. In particular, understanding death and being acquainted with it lies at the heart of what it means to be a Christian. Christians believe death is a passage toward eternal life. Earthly life is meant to be a preparation for death, and every day is an opportunity to build relationships, reconcile with others and settle unfinished business, no matter how fragile or sick we are. A death is not good because it is controlled, premature or seemingly painless, but because it is an integral part of life which is lived to the full and till the end. A good death concerns the whole community which surrounds the dying person with particular care and partakes in end-of-life rituals that are not only a form of accompaniment but also allow people to live their last days of life with peace, and without fear.

Perhaps one way to go about this would be to consider changing the social care and medical infrastructure so that fewer people can die in hospital settings, rather than at home, surrounded by their loved ones. This might, at once, lead to a re-familiarity with death and help us understand just what a good and dignified death really means.

 

Photo by Kampus Production.

Share this article to the following:

Sign up here for a fortnightly roundup of our best articles.

Continue reading

Sign up for a weekly roundup of our best articles