Dear new councillors: I’m afraid there is no money

X
LinkedIn
Facebook
Lana Hempsall

Lana is the Co-Founder of Conservatives in Energy and a former Conservative Councillor.

Congratulations on winning last week’s election. I know, from my own experience, the exhilaration of watching ballot papers being counted and an election victory after months or even years of campaigning. Now you must prepare to put into effect the promises you made on the doorstep that could make a genuine difference to your community. You’ll be in for a shock.

Within a few days of Cabinet positions being filled and officer briefings being completed, what will become clear is the scale of restraints on anything you had planned or promised in the election campaign. I still remember the time after being elected when I sat down to study the council budget plans for spending for the years ahead. There was little which was truly within local control. The numbers did not reflect a series of political choices so much as a set of obligations that had to be met. Much of the spending had already been determined in advance, shaped by obligations that could, for the most part, not be adjusted in any way.

The reason for that becomes apparent very quickly. A large and increasing share of your council’s budget is already tied directly to the costs of the welfare state simply paid for at a local level. This includes support for older people who require care, provision for children in the care system and assistance for families with complex needs. These now account for a huge share of council expenditures, in some cases up to 78% of the budget. Worse still, these are statutory responsibilities that cannot be wished away. It is the authority’s legal responsibility and those that apply for or need funding cannot be refused if they meet the criteria — and you have no influence in setting or amending those criteria. The result is that, while these welfare costs rise inexorably, they squeeze expenditure for every other spending area.

The effect of this becomes starker over time. In recent years, and particularly post pandemic, demand for care services has grown enormously. Indeed, since the pandemic, over 1.7 million children, approximately one-in-five pupils, require SEND support. And, as demand for these services grows, an ever-larger proportion of funding is drawn toward meeting those needs. The consequence is felt across the rest of the budget, where decisions increasingly involve weighing what can be maintained against what may have to be reduced or postponed. Services that are visible and widely used tend to feel the impact most directly.

I saw this play out repeatedly during my 15 years as a councillor in different authorities. With more resources needed to be devoted to welfare, less funding is available for the services that other residents use every day. Libraries forced to cut back opening hours, road maintenance delayed and investment in public spaces becoming harder to sustain. This can create the impression that politicians are delivering less, even when overall spending is actually rising.

From the perspective of residents, this can be difficult to reconcile. Expectations of local government have remained relatively constant, while the distribution of spending has shifted in ways that are less immediately apparent. Councils and mayors may be allocating more resources overall, yet the services people interact with on a daily basis appear diminished.

It is difficult to understand this shift without looking at what has been happening nationally. Welfare spending, particularly on disability and incapacity benefits, has been rising rapidly and is projected to approach £100 billion by the end of the decade. At the same time, the number of people out of work due to long-term sickness has increased significantly in recent years, rising by approximately 400,000 since the pandemic to over 2.5 million.

There will be those just elected who do not want to reduce this area of spending. Fine if that is your outlook, but then you must face the consequences with less money for what else you want. These trends shape the environment in which local government now operates. As welfare-related spending expands, it defines the boundaries within which decisions are made, influencing both the range of services that can be supported and the choices available to those responsible for allocating resources.

For those just elected, their time will be spent coping with the local consequences of a system whose scale and direction are largely determined elsewhere. Much of the pressure you will encounter stems from that dynamic. While additional funding can provide some relief, particularly in the short term, it does not alter the underlying trajectory if demand continues to rise. The space for discretionary services becomes narrower, and the range of services councils are able to sustain begins to contract.

While local government is becoming increasingly shaped by welfare, that is not something that can be resolved through local decisions. It requires a Government willing to address the soaring costs of welfare dependency. So, if I had a single recommendation for what you might want to do first, it is to book yourself an appointment at the surgery of the local MP — perhaps with council colleagues in tow — and ask them to support the reforms that will enable you to fulfil the promises you made on doorsteps in the run-up to seventh of May. Else, the next time a cutback on local services that MP opposes happens, the blame will at least be laid squarely at their door.

 

If you want to read about how local welfare funding could be improved, we recommend the essay by Henry Hill in our recent book ‘Mending the net? A new centre-right approach to social security’.

Original photo by Emil Kalibradov.

Share this article to the following:

X
LinkedIn
Facebook
You have no influence in setting or amending those criteria.
Sign up here for a fortnightly roundup of our best articles.

Continue reading

Sign up for a weekly roundup of our best articles