PETER HITCHENS:
Dear Polly,
All my life energetic, admirable and courageous people have tried to help those who suffered in the cold glare of strict old-fashioned sexual morality. Who can blame them? The mothers of children born out of wedlock; the children themselves; the women deserted or abused by feckless men: all deserved better than they got in the chilly, disapproving Britain of the 1950s.
People love to disapprove, and the spiteful joy that can be obtained through looking down on others is a secret nasty pleasure which is too seldom admitted or described. It was horrid then, and it is horrid now. Oddly enough, that pleasure now survives mostly in the glow of righteous contempt which the enlightened liberal classes feel for the despised social conservatives who they have driven to the margins of society.
When, 20 years ago, I wrote my first book The Abolition of Britain, I found a fascinating thing. Britain before the 1960s had been full of campaigners trying to make life better for the sort of people I described above, the outsiders in a society based on lifelong marriage. They fought for changes in legal status, and for the use of kinder words to describe that status. But then they began to campaign instead for a social revolution in which the norms would change completely. In most cases, I think they thought these goals were identical. They were not.
The question that came to trouble me, and as an only partially-reformed six-cylinder 1960s bohemian they troubled me more than most, was: what will become of the children? Ending the stigma against children born outside marriage was laudable and right, but creating a society in which many more children were brought up in fatherless families, or even in children’s homes, was not.
The same went for broken marriages. Who wants to force anyone to stay inside a dead or abusive marriage? Not I, but making marriage so easily dissoluble that it offered no stability at all was surely not the answer, especially where there were small children involved. Surely this was not what was meant to happen. Can anyone have actually wanted the scourge of fatherless families and broken homes which came upon us over the last 50 years?
Yet those who campaigned for these changes do not seem to regret them very much, or to call now for adjustments to make them kinder to children. On the contrary, they continue to push in the same direction. Have they just not noticed? Or was their target always a different kind of society, and are the children just collateral damage in a utopian war?
Regards,
Peter
—
POLLY MACKENZIE:
Dear Peter,
It’s a funny thing, stigma. It is a society’s ways of policing its boundaries and regulating behaviour. It works not just because consequences are imposed on those who don’t obey – like being ostracised in the way you describe – but also because people internalise the shame. You acknowledge that, sometimes, leaving a relationship is the right decision, but you want people to be deterred from doing it so often, because you can’t believe it’s the right decision quite as often as it seems to happen these days.
What does that deterrent look like? Surely it is shame, and its wearisome sister, guilt. To be deterred from creating ‘broken families’, people need to know in their hearts that it is harmful to children to bring them up in unstable or single parent households, and weigh that in the balance when they make choices about their relationships.
I’m afraid I have a problem with that, because shame is a poison.
Let’s look at the evidence. Yes, children do seem statistically to do better in married couples. But that’s largely because of the characteristics of people who get married. They are richer as individuals and then, because there are two of them, they are infinitely more likely to have two incomes than a single parent family. And – though the data can’t prove this – as marriage becomes rarer, the people who get married are likely to be those who are most committed to one another. That’s probably why marriages are lasting longer these days than they used to.
As you say, since the 1950s, marriage has become rarer, and step-families and single parent families have become more common. If those modern types of family really were so harmful to children, then why are our children doing so much better than they did back then? Child and infant mortality rates are lower – even though there are far more cars on the roads. Literacy rates are higher – even though we have far more children in our schools with English as a second language. Child poverty rates are lower. The homes our children grow up in are warmer, cleaner and safer.
Given that children’s lives have not deteriorated as family patterns have changed, on what basis should we be sending single or divorced parents on a guilt trip?
Perhaps you will attribute these improvements in children’s lives to economic growth. But where has that prosperity come from? Much of it has come from women’s liberation. Three quarters of working age women now have a job in the paid economy – or at least they did until COVID-19. Of course, it is more than possible to have a stable marriage as well as a job. But freedom is not easily divisible. Women who work have the choice to leave relationships; women who don’t get stuck. We cannot have all the prosperity of the last 70 years without the freedom of the last 70 years.
You are right that if we liberate women, and destigmatise relationship breakdown, there will be more divorces and more single parents. We shouldn’t pretend that away, but neither should we pretend we can precision engineer every family to be precisely the way we want it. You cannot take away stigma from single parents and keep the shame that stops people becoming single parents. You cannot take stigma away from gay people without giving more people the confidence to come out.
Shame is poison. You believe a stable marriage is the best bet for a child. So you must also believe children in single or step parent families have been dealt a shabby hand. You surely want the best for them. That means we have to celebrate those families: we have to offer them pride instead of shame, whatever the consequences. Talk of “broken homes” and “fatherless families” does not help anyone, not least because you seem to have forgotten that there are stable marriages between women where children are brought up by two loving parents, neither of which is a father.
Perhaps you are right that the confident celebration of single parents, gay parents, step-families, trans-parents and blended families will mean a few more people leave a relationship that could, in fact, have been saved. But the alternative is worse. Children should not be collateral damage in a utopian war: I agree. But children are at risk in the crusade to homogenise human experience, too. Isn’t your yearning for tidy little married families behind every door a version of utopia, too?
All the best,
Polly
—
PETER HITCHENS:
Dear Polly,
I don’t think you have actually read what I have written. I occupy the position of the vanquished, seeking mitigation of the terms of my surrender. I am well aware that my side has lost the war, though I do not think we have lost the argument. That argument has never been had, as your response demonstrates. I ask only for the victors in the culture wars to ask themselves if they have got what they wanted. On what measure do you think “our children” are “doing so much better than they did back then”? I suppose a Thatcherite might measure the quality of life solely in material terms, but I am concerned about what sort of men and women we are bringing up, and I think that stability, constancy, parental love, good examples and authority – which used to be available in the poorest homes and now are not – are more important than money, foreign holidays or material goods.
Nowhere do I call for stigma, or shame or guilt or ostracism. These forces, as I pointed out, always exist and belong to the dominant elite in any society, which is at present you and your allies. I think they are often misused and nowadays they are cheerfully aimed against me by the revolutionaries, who are quick to classify people such as me as haters and bigots, marginalising our opinions as toxic pathologies, while misrepresenting them. If you are so against shame and stigma, then you should tell your own side to stop using them.
Children, especially boys, do better with fathers, and worse without them: this is observable and is not a statistical quirk caused by the fact that marriage is more common among the better off. In my childhood, stable lifelong marriage was universal in all classes and at all levels of income. Mine is a moral argument. Yours is an economic one, and seems to be about what you call “prosperity”, and what you call “freedom”.
No man fights freedom, as Karl Marx rightly noted. He fights at most the freedom of others. In the last half-century, adults have fought and won a great deal of freedom at the expense of children, born and unborn. No doubt all our bank accounts have got bigger as a result, and our stock of material goods has grown too, but we are diminished as human beings. This is why I am not a Thatcherite, and, as it seems, you are.
Regards,
Peter
—
POLLY MACKENZIE:
Dear Peter,
Oh, Peter. You seem so sad and angry. Let me tell you where I think you’re right, if only to prove that I have read your words, and thoughtfully.
There is a tendency in most public policy campaigns to advocate for change and systematically ignore the downsides it brings with it. You’ll know GK Chesterton’s adage about fences: we should only remove them once we understand why they were put there, lest we get charged by a bull. I understand your outrage that the shift in family norms is talked about by its advocates as if there are only upsides – whether they be abstract concepts like freedom, or practical improvements like fewer violently unhappy marriages. I do, however, agree with you that there are negative consequences, and we shouldn’t pretend them away.
Let me give you an example: women used to be the mainstay of community networks, because they were at home all day. That provided the infrastructure for a huge amount of informal social and childcare, of neighbours as well as family. Now that more women than ever are working in the paid economy, communities are often more fragmented, and fewer people know their neighbours. We forgot to replace the unpaid work women did to keep our society going.
So what do we do about this? Do we send the women home again? Some conservatives will argue that we should. I think we should be more creative. For generations, we placed unpaid duties at the feet of women, and left men to earn the money and the power that comes with it. Instead we need to split the work – paid and unpaid – more justly between the genders. Far more men should work part time enabling them to take on a fair share of the domestic chores, child rearing and community labour that women have traditionally done.
If liberals and conservatives could listen to each other better, I think our society would be stronger. Progressives always want to change things, and forget to worry about the consequences. Conservatives are so worried about the consequences that they never want anything to change. If progressives would notice what gets lost in the tidal wave of change, they might be better at protecting it – or designing new ways to achieve it. If conservatives were open to new ways of achieving their old goals, they might not find themselves so sad and angry all the time.
We have a common goal, Peter. In your words: children brought up with stability, constancy, authority and parental love. My parents divorced and I had every one of those. My husband’s parents did not and he had barely any of them. So let’s be fixed in our ambition for what we want our children to experience, not the family structure in which they experience it.
All the best,
Polly
—
Peter Hitchens is a columnist for the Mail on Sunday. Polly Mackenzie is the Chief Executive of Demos. This letter exchange first appeared in our Centre Write magazine Family friendly?. Views expressed in this article are those of the authors, not necessarily those of Bright Blue.