‘In The Realm of the Last Man’ by Francis Fukuyama

X
LinkedIn
Facebook
Archie Sykes

Archie Sykes is a master’s student of politics at the American University of Beirut.

Francis Fukuyama was propelled to worldwide fame with his provocatively titled article, The End of History?, in which he argued that liberalism marked the end of the evolution of human political ideas, and whilst there will “be events to fill the pages of Foreign Affairs‘s yearly summaries of international relations,” there would no longer be a continuous and meaningful battle of ideas.

Since then, he has written extensively on international relations, political economy and democracy and, most recently, a new book: In The Realm of the Last Man. There, he has sought to bring many of his ideas together into a story of his and his family’s life.

In the Realm of the Last Man is in many ways a slightly strange book which is mostly an analysis of the evolution of Fukuyama’s work peppered with small anecdotes about his life, his family and his hobbies. Reading it feels very much like reading something that your grandfather would tell you. There is a clear strain of thought, but one which occasionally and very randomly branches off into strange tangents, such as when he spends a couple of chapters, separated by discussions of politics, discussing the process of woodworking and the machines he has used.

These sections, which may on the surface seem slightly pointless, bring a degree of charm and humour, changing it from a Politics 101 book to a more homely memoir of an intellectual who has shaped Western politics. It is a bit like the Letters of Abelard and Heloise, but with politics instead of theology, and carpentry instead of romance.

Spaced between these tangents is an introduction to Fukuyama and to political theory in the guise of explanations of the thinking of Leo Strauss, Kojève, Alan Bloom and Samuel Huntingdom, all thinkers that play a pivotal role in Fukuyama’s life. These chapters provide those who have had little exposure to these different thinkers an introduction to their thought without the chapters being bogged down in excessively deep political theory that one would find in academic texts (for those readers interested in this, Fukuyama provides a list of important books and articles from these authors and others that can help them start their journey).

Whilst the book is not as deep as Fukuyama’s previous work, for those with little experience of his thought, it provides a fantastic introduction. Throughout the book, there are chapters and sections broadly dedicated to many of his longer works, with these chapters offering short and easy to read introductions to their more academic and hefty versions.

This includes a section where he discusses his interest in the topic of trust and the role it plays in influencing the economy of different countries. His arguments for the importance of high levels of trust in building large businesses provide a shortened version of his much longer and older book, Trust: The Social Virtues and the Creation of Prosperity.

These sections also provide space for Fukuyama to discuss how and where changes in global politics have led him to reconsider his conclusions. Conceding, for example, that whilst in the nineties he would have described the US as having a relatively high-trust society, he is beginning to see that position come undone as America becomes divided.

Unsurprisingly, Fukuyama also uses the book to mount a small defence of The End of History? against those who have not “bothered to read the last five chapters of my book.” In his discussion, he explores how the West has entered the phase of “The Last Man” in which it has completed its ideological struggle and will be forced to engage in the economic management of their societies. This lack of struggle is the core reason, in his eyes, as to why we are seeing the rise of far-left and far-right movements across the Western world.

He uses the MAGA movement — a political movement to which he levels frequent attacks throughout the book — as an example of this, with a special focus on January 6th. On that fateful day, he argues, it was not the economically disadvantaged that rallied behind Donald Trump, but the secure, white middle-class America that had, deep down, simply got bored of not having something to fight for.

This idea is backed up by polling. Polling in April 2024 showed the Republican Party as most popular amongst the middle-income and upper-middle-income voters — the Party’s traditional voter base — and, importantly, least popular with low-income votes. These voters are in the phase of the last man, enjoying rising incomes and political freedom that removes their need to fight for recognition and shows the victory of Western liberalism. Despite this economic success, these voters have still rallied around Trump, who has promised to give them something to fight for and has, as Fukuyama argues, given them a way out of simply “caretaking the museum of human history.”

Fukuyama’s book is not the most complex book, and for some readers, this will be a downside; it is instead a primer on his political thought and the thought of those who were around him throughout the seventies, eighties, nineties and noughties. To those with little to no experience of his work, this book may be the best place to start. After reading it, you will be pointed in the direction of Fukuyama’s works that most interest you, whether it is looking at why liberal democracy is struggling now (Liberalism and Its Discontents) or political economy (the aforementioned Trust).

But, to those already familiar with the ideas discussed by Fukuyama, this book will feel shallow, and the tangents into domestic life will read as pointless ramblings on life detached from proper political philosophy.

 

The original image is Francis Fukuyama speaking in 1996 at the University in St. Gallen, by Regina Kühne.

Share this article to the following:

Voters have still rallied around Trump, who has promised to give them something to fight for and has, as Fukuyama argues, given them a way out of simply “caretaking the museum of human history.”
Sign up here for a fortnightly roundup of our best articles.

Continue reading

Sign up for a weekly roundup of our best articles