Jeff Webster: Tackling the housing crisis

X
LinkedIn
Facebook

The Government has announced plans to increase house construction. This is sound policy and the Government is right to focus on ways to increase supply. But we shouldn’t lose sight of the fact this is a long-term solution to a long-term problem. New supply has undershot demand for decades, and it will takes decades more for a surplus of new supply to correct the imbalance

Econometric studies conducted by Oxford Economics indicate that adding 300,000 new houses would only lower prices by about 1% a year. That’s peanuts in the context of recent house price increases and the gap would-be house buyers need to bridge to buy their first home. In addition, in the short-term (i.e. within an election cycle) the Government’s efforts are likely to be counter-productive to their chances of re-election in 2022. On balance they are likely to upset more nimbyish voters by construction works springing up on their favourite local green or brown-field site than create favourable first time buyers helped by more supply coming online.

Besides, shortage of supply is not even the most significant factor behind the unaffordability of houses for the millennial generation. Regional variation is another. Demand outstripping supply is far greater in or around London than in Northern England. This is a factor of the relative attractiveness of London as place to live and centralise corporate, social and cultural activity. The solution to this, naturally, is not to decrease the allure of London but to boost the appeal of other regions, thus shifting demand within existing supply.

The largest factor, however, as shown by the same Oxford Economics analysis has been looser borrowing conditions (pre-2008) and lower interest rates (post-2008). By lowering the cost of covering a mortgage they increased how much households could afford to borrow in order to acquire a house. Simplistically, when interest rates halve households can borrow twice as much whilst maintaining the same monthly interest payments. That drives a doubling of house prices.

The issue for the Government is those two factors, as with the shortage of supply, do not have short-term solutions. London took many decades to become such a magnet for households. The Northern Powerhouse could do the same for the region around Manchester and Sheffield, but will take at least as long.

Leaving aside the independence of the Bank of England, interest rates could technically be increased rapidly. But the damage to the economy would more than offset any benefit to aspiring home-owners. The ensuing tightening of credit and house price crash would create a recession that combined the worst of the 1992 and 2008 versions. The truth is house prices are like balloons at a children’s party. They inflate to smiles and cheers, but deflate with screeches and tears. The only safe way to shrink them is slowly and after the party has finished.  

So what can the Government do in the short-term that would help more of the millennial generation onto the housing ladder?

For that it is useful to look at the pinch point. It isn’t the monthly interest and mortgage repayments aspiring home-buyers would struggle with. Today’s low interest rates would in this case be their friend ensuring for many their monthly outgoings were no more than they are currently forking out on rent. Rather it is saving for a deposit necessary to be allowed a mortgage that is the largest obstacle. As house prices have risen and lending standards tightened, the sum required as a deposit to get on the ladder has risen many multiples faster than average earnings. ‎Consequently, it takes someone earning anything other than an exceptionally high salary several years longer to save for one.

There is precious little the Government can do in short-term to turbo-boost disposable incomes above what it is already doing to raise the minimum wage and income tax thresholds. Nor can they dare trigger a house price crash. Earnings and house prices diverged speedily but will have to come back into alignment gradually. Furthermore, with memory fresh of the financial crisis, it would be ill advised to lower lending standards on minimum deposits.

Thus, the only short-term option remaining is to introduce some form of wealth transfer to fast-track today’s renters the capital they need to purchase their first place. To paraphrase a famous Turkish proverb, if Muhammad can’t get up the mountain then the mountain must come down to Muhammad.

But from where could this wealth be transferred? The one place there is a relative abundance is the equity of home-owners that have seen material price gains and have largely paid off their mortgage. It is important to remember this wealth is not permanent. It does pass down the generations. The issue is rather that it doesn’t happen early enough. As the Resolution Foundation showed in a recent paper, it mostly gets transferred when the recipients are in their 50s and 60s, not their 20s and 30s when budding families are typically looking to get their first home.

So the trick would be for the Government to encourage a transfer of some of this paper wealth earlier, when it is most needed. This could be done through well designed incentives, such as a relief from inheritance tax from “gifting” equity in their home to help direct descendants put down a deposit on first home. If the parental home is sold before death then the equity transfer would be deducted from the proceeds of the sale. In many cases all that would have been passed up are some of the capital gains made on the house. That should bearable given most people with descendants already at home-acquiring age are no looking to upsize their own dwellings.

That would work wonders for the roughly 50% of 20s to 30s who stand to inherit a high-valued parental property. But what about those who do not stand to inherit such largess? The cynical view would be that there is no magic bullet that helps everyone and there are likely enough new capital owners created from the fortunate half to boost the party’s election chances. The braver view would be to look at re-lowering the inheritance tax threshold, allowing those who gift equity to their descendants to offset the impact if it is used to buy a first home, and use the additional tax revenue from those who do not to explicitly support the less fortunate half, for example through a super-charged Help to Buy scheme.

Jeff Webster is a member of Bright Blue. The views expressed in this article are those of the author, not necessarily those of Bright Blue.

Share this article to the following:

X
LinkedIn
Facebook
Sign up here for a fortnightly roundup of our best articles.

Continue reading

Sign up for a weekly roundup of our best articles