Arya Chanda: The Lib Dems can only win if they keep their heads down

X
LinkedIn
Facebook

After a high-octane election campaign, Ed Davey appeared full of triumph at the Liberal Democrat party conference in Brighton last month. After all, with 72 MPs, 2024 represents their best result in over a century. If he wishes to make further advances, however, he must not lose focus on the tried-and-tested Lib Dem tactic of localised campaigning.

At the conference, Davey outlined the his vision: to position the Lib Dems as the  “reasonable opposition” to Labour and to replace the Conservatives as the official opposition by targeting more “blue wall” and “rural seats.” 

Considering that the Tories only have 49 more seats, this does not seem as outlandish as it would have in years past. Yet, if the Lib Dems are serious about achieving these goals, there are some uncomfortable questions to answer about the potential schism between the views of Lib Dem MPs and their voters: especially where it comes to economic and European policy.

First, in economic platform, the Lib Dem 2024 manifesto arguably outflanked Labour’s with a jump to the left, offering up a smorgasbord of progressive goodies: from the expansion of social care to the hiking of Capital Gains Tax (CGT). Not exactly the free-market ideas you’d expect to come out of the Orange Book, which guided the party in years past. Bobby Dean, the new Lib Dem MP for Carshalton and Wallington, remarked that the current crop of MPs is rather much more like the “Charles Kennedy-Paddy Ashdown years than the Clegg years.” 

It is difficult to square this with the fact that the bulk of MPs now represent what The Economist describes as “lovely”  England. For the next five years, the Cheltenham Races, Henley Regatta and Glyndebourne Opera will all take place in firm Lib Dem territory and contain some of the most fiscally conservative voters in the country. 

Take Henley and Thame, for example – an Oxfordshire seat, once the stomping ground of Michael Heseltine and Boris Johnson, gained by the Lib Dems in 2024. It has an average house price of nearly double the national average, as well as a significantly higher gross household income. Electoral Calculus rates it as 15 degrees more economically right-wing than the national average, meaning the median view in Henley is one which believes much more in lower taxes and a smaller state. Despite this it has just elected an MP standing on a ‘soft left’ manifesto with a majority of 6,000 votes. 

This conflict between economically progressive MPs and fiscally conservative voters could cause a serious hurdle to Lib Dem success, especially as they look to win over more former Conservative voters to take Tory seats at the next election. 

The second big division between Liberal Democrat MPs and their voters is the direction of the party’s policy on Europe. Whilst the Lib Dems secured a similar vote share under Jo Swinson in 2019 as they did in 2024, with an explicitly anti-Brexit manifesto, this resulted in a poorly distributed vote and just 11 seats. Davey’s party, combining tactical voting with its vocal focus on more local issues like sewage and rivers, has been able to build a successful electoral coalition that stretches from not just Remain voting suburbia but also back into previously held, rural, Brexit-voting areas. Indeed, approximately 30% of 2024 Lib Dem voters voted Leave and, in a number of Lib Dem seats, Leave won by large margins. For example, in North Cornwall and North Shropshire, Leave won with well over 60% of the vote. 

Although at this year’s conference discussion of European policy was tactfully limited to youth mobility and a vague notion of “fixing our broken relationship with Europe,” as the Parliamentary term progresses the party could be tempted to return to its old, more vocally anti-Brexit ways. A shift in European policy could risk alienating many of the Leave voters who helped deliver such a strong result for the Lib Dems in 2024.

In fact, despite Ed Davey’s valid optimism about the prospects of the Lib Dems gaining more seats in future, success for the Lib Dems will not be delivered primarily by policy. After all, their result in 2024 was achieved by an effective delivery of the classic Lib Dem strategy of tactical anti-Conservative voting and strong local campaigns that built upon years of local council successes. 

If the Conservatives lurch further right and if Labour’s unpopularity continues to grow, the Lib Dems could capitalise on anti-Tory sentiment without having to take responsibility for Labour’s failures. However, if their policies distance the voter base that brought them success in 2024, they will struggle to fully seize this opportunity, even with rising dissatisfaction toward the other parties. As Boris Johnson said of the Lib Dems back in 2002, “The last thing you want is publicity for your policies,” because, while the Lib Dems may not win on good policy, they can certainly lose on bad policy.

So, perhaps, for the foreseeable future, they should keep their heads down and their crash helmets on – much as Ed Davey does.

 

Arya Chanda is a Bright Blue member and a Laidlaw Scholar at University College London.

 

Share this article to the following:

Sign up here for a fortnightly roundup of our best articles.

Continue reading

Sign up for a weekly roundup of our best articles