‘Melania’ by Melania Trump

X
LinkedIn
Facebook
Mary Lucia Darst

Mary Lucia Darst is a filmmaker, classical musician, opera director and CUNY-Newmark School of Journalism scholar. She was also a Distinguished Fellow with the Richmond International Film Festival.

Melania, the new documentary on Melania Trump, is exactly what it purports to be: a documentary on the current First Lady of the United States (FLOTUS). Filmed during the ‘lame duck’ period between when Donald Trump won a second term in November 2024 and his inauguration in January 2025, Melania is not a biographical documentary, nor did the filmmaker claim it to be. Instead, it is an exploration of being the First Lady of the United States (also acronymised as FLOTUS). The hook is that she is only the second FLOTUS to serve non-consecutive terms, the first being Frances Folsom Cleveland, whose husband Grover Cleveland was both the twenty-second and twenty-fourth President of the United States (POTUS).

Despite the branding of the film as ‘controversial,’ it really is not. The ‘controversy’ lay in that FLOTUS announced during the lame duck period that she would not move to Washington, DC, for the second term, though she would travel in as needed to discharge her official responsibilities. As a scandal, the matter was blown out of proportion by uninformed individuals who evidently confused social event attendance with matters of state.

The precedent for FLOTUS lies between Martha Washington, wife of the first POTUS, and Abigail Adams, wife of the second POTUS. Since George Washington made clear at the time of his election that he and his wife were a package deal, the American people accepted that she would have unlimited access to the chief executive and be present at all times, in which last capacity her role formalised immediately into being available as an official witness and hostess at state events. Martha Washington was a ‘domestic goddess’ type who focussed her energies on running the household. In comparison, her successor, Abigail Adams, eschewed the domestic side, which she left to housekeeping staff, and served as a policy adviser — or, as Americans would call it, advisor — and political strategist to her husband.

Since then, the first lady has had considerable latitude to choose if she will be a domestic creature, a social beast or a political animal. Across forty-seven first ladies (or, to be pedantic, forty-five, since two of them were and are the same person with non-consecutive terms), the US has had ones who preferred to be private or domestic, spending their time redecorating and staying out of public affairs, to ones who attended Cabinet meetings and actively shaped policy, to ones with celebrity-style personas entirely focussed on social engagements and couture.

Much like Aesop’s man, child, and donkey fable, not everyone in the electorate was, or is, pleased, regardless of what choices FLOTUS makes. There will always be a group ready to brand her a malingerer, a Svengali, or a Marie-Antoinette, depending somewhat on her choices but also on the political leanings of the accusers.

When the current FLOTUS made her announcement regarding not moving to Washington, DC, the immediate backlash fell into the ‘malingerer’ category. By following FLOTUS during the lame duck period, Melania addresses these criticisms through showing FLOTUS’s ongoing involvement in policy development and fundamentally argues that, in the twenty-first century, post-COVID-19 pandemic world, remote work is open to everyone: even the First Lady of the United States. Consider that, Nigel.

 

The original phot is a work of an employee of the Executive Office of the President of the United States, taken or made as part of that person’s official duties. For the sake of clarity, the director of the film ‘Melania’ is Brett Ratner, not, in fact, Melania Trump.

Share this article to the following:

There will always be a group ready to brand a FLOTUS a malingerer, a Svengali, or a Marie-Antoinette.
Sign up here for a fortnightly roundup of our best articles.

Continue reading

Sign up for a weekly roundup of our best articles