There is a stroke of irony in that the story of King Arthur captured the imagination of none other than the descendants of the very invaders King Arthur fought against. Specifically, King Edward I sought to do what Arthur did, beginning with conquering Wales.
He then briefly conquered Scotland, until his son, Edward II, lost it thanks to Robert the Bruce. Eventually, Edward’s successors expanded this vision to Ireland, gradually conquering it over time. Only after centuries of English effort was it a Scotsman who accidentally unified it all: King James I. He inherited both the English and Scottish crowns through a fluke of history — the oddity of the English running out of direct successors, combined with his blood tie to the English crown through his great-grandmother’s marriage to an English king.
Thus, in a bizarre turn of events, the Arthurian dream that so obsessed English kings was made reality by a Scottish monarch in 1603. This union changed the face of the British Isles. Crucially, it ended the bloody history of warfare between England and Scotland forever.
It is worth remembering that, throughout the Middle Ages, from the departure of Rome to the Renaissance, England and Scotland clashed repeatedly in various forms. The Anglo-Scottish Wars — which some historians date from 1296 to 1603 — saw unimaginable bloodshed and death, even setting aside the conflicts prior to that era. The creation of the Union was an end to centuries of slaughter.
That was only the beginning of the wonder the Union would produce. The synthesis of Scottish and English ideas transformed the world. For instance, Adam Smith’s The Wealth of Nations, written by a Scottish economist, met the brilliant insights of English philosophers like John Locke on the consent of the governed, paving the way for the democratic societies much of the world lives in today.
In engineering, the Union brought together great Scottish and English minds to reshape human industry. A prime example is the steam engine, invented by Thomas Savery, an Englishman, and perfected by James Watt, a Scot — creating the technological breakthrough that launched the Industrial Age.
These are only a few fruits of the relationship between Scotland and England, and a similar story one could also be told with the inclusion of Wales and Ireland.
Furthermore, the unification of the British Isles led to an empire that covered a third of the globe — the largest ever seen in human history. Nations that had once slaughtered each other joined together to change the face of the world in ways none of them could have achieved alone.
This is not to say mistakes were not made. The Irish Potato Famine, the Highland Clearances and the Welsh Not left deep scars that have never fully healed. Many English politicians also too often belittle the non-English nations with reminders from Westminster that they are mere poor relations to barely be tolerated, naturally sparking deep resentment.
This resentment pushes voters toward nationalist and independence-leaning parties: the Scottish National Party in Scotland, Sinn Féin in Northern Ireland and Plaid Cymru in Wales.
The general rallying cry of these parties — even if the exact words are rarely used — can be summarized by a Welsh proverb: “Better a cottage of my own than a palace of another.” Reminds me of another slogan: “Take back control.”
The underlying argument is that it is better to have your own humble home, even if it is modest, than to live in greater comfort as a poor tenant of a greater power.
The operative effect of this narrative is to make non-English Brits feel as though they do not truly belong in the Union — a feeling easily cultivated in a world where “British” is far too often used as a simple synonym for “English.”
To remedy this, all citizens of the UK must feel a true sense of ownership in a shared British identity and believe they have a genuine stake in the nation. This cannot be achieved simply by giving local mayors and councils more decision-making power, smart though that idea may be.
Nor will it be solved by a written constitution heavily rooted in English law, which would merely codify British culture into a distinctly English mould. Decades of devolution have shown that granting regional powers alone does not halt the push for separation.
Instead, reforming the House of Lords into an Assembly of Nations and Regions would provide a permanent platform where Scottish, Welsh and Northern Irish voices are guaranteed to be heard and acted upon. It would serve as an unmistakable vehicle proving that the non-English peoples of the UK matter and are not ignored as poor relations.
This reform avoids the common pitfall of devolution, wherein regional governments blame Westminster for their own failures, while also neutralising the slippery slope of endless demands for incremental powers.
It also avoids the dangers of a written constitution, which would likely attempt to enforce uniform values across all UK nations — indeed, any majority arrangement in a democracy, including a constitution, would naturally reflect England’s preferences thanks to its population size.
Reforming the House of Lords may be the final move to save the Union — the very entity that transformed warring mediaeval kingdoms into a Great Britain that shaped the world.
The original image is a painting of King James VI of Scotland and James I of England by Paul van Somer, c. 1620, in the public domain.
