When we look at the modern right at work, we are most likely going to notice the following pattern: if a legal decision goes against them, then the courts are enemies of the people. If impossible promises are just that, then the civil service is ‘too politicised.’ The public is promised tax cuts running alongside more funding for the NHS and public services. Anyone who asks too many probing questions about any of this, or dares to apply logic, is part of the ‘woke mob.’
Suffice to say, the modern right-wing has devolved into the politics of all noise, no temperament; a far cry from the likes of David Cameron, Ted Heath, Harold Macmillan and, crucially here, Roy Jenkins.
Roy Jenkins was a liberal social democrat, someone who believed that the answers to Britain’s problems could be found at the synthesis of liberalism and social democracy. He was a founder of the SDP, at the time a pillar of liberal-left politics, a Europhile — even becoming the President of the European Commission in 1977 — and should be considered an unlikely hero to the centre-right.
Populists are capturing the right. From the UK Conservative Party purging centrists under Boris Johnson through Kemi Badenoch claiming that the Party will no longer accept moderate ideas to Donald Trump’s hostile takeover of the Republicans, critics are being driven out and sycophancy is being brought in.
How Jenkins and the centre-right had once responded to populists is a familiar story. Labour’s shift towards the far left under Michael Foot led Jenkins to establish the SDP with Shirley Williams, David Owen and Bill Rodgers. In response to the Conservative Party’s shift towards the populism and the rise of Reform UK, some of Britain’s leading centre-right politicians have likewise founded Prosper UK.
While Prosper UK should be the natural vehicle for the centre-right to rebuild, it should learn from Jenkins while it is in its formative years. Call the following a borrowable inheritance; ideas that transcend the left, right and centre; ideas that can unite moderates and everyone who simply wants Britain to do better without the melodrama:
First, freedom. Roy Jenkins was the most progressive Home Secretary in British history, the architect of the “civilised society.” He decriminalised homosexuality, liberalised divorce laws and ended theatre censorship. He understood that the state had no right to police individuals’ private consciences. The centre-right should carry forward the same sentiment.
This is hardly unfamiliar ground. Liberals and conservatives used to work together during the Coalition years to legalise same-sex marriage. The two can and should coalesce.
Second, institutions: Roy Jenkins was a parliamentarian’s parliamentarian, a man who revered parliament, the rule of law and the settled norms that hold a free society together, holding statesmanship and stewardship in high regard. He made the case for them long before populism had taken hold, and so it needs to be taken up by the centre-right now: defence of our institutions against those who would seek to diminish them, especially when decisions are made that may run counter to their beliefs.
The alternative is an ungovernable nation that bends to the demands of those with the loudest voices rather than trusting due process and doing what is right.
And last, money. For all his liberal-left tendencies, Roy Jenkins was never a run-of-the-mill leftist. He took the chancellorship in November 1967, amid the devaluation crisis, and what he did deserves the centre-right’s admiration. He restored order through sheer rigour, adopted an austere attitude to spending and refused to make impossible promises on what the country could not afford.
He achieved all of this without giving an inch on his socially progressive outlook on life.
Of course, Jenkins was by no means a right-winger, and what is being borrowed here is deliberately narrow. Jenkins still believed in redistribution and an active economic state, and his intolerance to any form of inequality runs further than many on the right would be comfortable embracing.
What the centre-right should borrow, however, is not his politics, but his approach to it. He refused to entertain extremism, trusting in a politics of moderation, pragmatism and good governance.
The civilised society was never the sole property of Jenkins or the centre-left; it is there for anyone serious enough and brave enough to claim it in a climate that mistakes decency for weakness. To counter-balance the populists with the loudest voice, the centre-right could learn some lessons from Jenkins.
Original photo of Lord Jenkins of Hillhead by Jean-Louis Debaize.
