Bartek Staniszewski: The future of the right

X
LinkedIn
Facebook

“If we don’t stand for freedom, we stand for nothing.” Steve Baker, a mainstay of Westminster politics up until his loss in the recent general election, told the audience of the recent ‘Future of the Right’ panel organised by the Institute of Economic Affairs. But, as charismatic as Steve was on that panel, I am not sure that being right-wing does come down to freedom. As important as freedom is, what distinguishes the right throughout its history is rather something else altogether – value realism.

The terms right-wing and left-wing originated in the time of the French Revolution. In the French Assemblées, those in support of the King sat to his right, while those in support of the Revolution sat to his left. This does not mean that to be right- or left-wing comes down merely to whether one is pro-monarchist or not, but it does highlight the important role that French revolutionary ideals continue to play in modern-day politics. The motto of the Revolution – and now also of the French Fifth Republic – was liberté, égalité, fraternité. Liberty, equality and fraternity continue to be the central concepts in the political life of all western democracies. But all three, including liberté, originated as the ideals of the left. Today’s right is often happy to co-opt them, but those values are by no means essentially right-wing.

Perhaps what makes the difference is how the right and the left understand those three ideals. For the great right-wing libertarian philosopher Robert Nozick, the liberty that matters is liberty from interference. This contrasts with the views of great left-wing thinkers like Rousseau and Marx, who were very concerned with our liberty to do certain things – like participate in the political process.

But many very right-wing figures do not share Nozick’s views. Benito Mussolini once claimed that ” truth is evident to all who are unblinded by dogmatism that men nowadays are tired of liberty.” Fascists, as well as many other right-wingers, are not particularly concerned with safeguarding Nozick’s notion of liberty.

Perhaps the essence of being right-wing is looking to the past. “People who never look back to their ancestors will not look forward to posterity,” writes Edmund Burke in scathing review of the French Revolution. Indeed, in the UK, ‘right-wing’ and ‘conservative’ are often used somewhat interchangeably. But this, too, is not quite right. One of the founders of Italian fascism, the far-right Filippo Marinetti, writes “we want no part of it, the past, we the young and strong Futurists!” Conversely, the left is also not beyond hearkening back to a better past. As the eminent podcaster Dominic Sandbrook once wrote, “n the rose-tinted imagination of the Labour Party, 1945 has become a brief, shining episode of collective solidarity and socialist idealism, after which everything has been betrayal and decline.”

The essence of the right lies somewhere else. In 2019, Jonathan Haidt, together with four other academics, published a paper on moral preferences held by those with different political views. What they found is that the moral concerns of American left-wing persons stretch far beyond the entities that we ordinarily think of as morally valuable. While most people’s moral concerns stretch as far out as their friends and family, other humans and perhaps also sentient animals, the moral concerns of left-wing people go as far as “all natural things in the universe including inert entities, such as rocks.” Indeed, those who identified as the most left-wing on a scale from one to seven allocated the same moral value to humans as they do to non-human entities – which includes animals and plants but also rocks and light particles and everything else in existence. In other words, everything is valuable. But, if everything is valuable, nothing is.

This is where the essence of the right lies. When I wrote a letter to the Guardian praising the property ombudsman for stopping landlords from banning families with children from their properties, and bemoaning the UK’s low fertility rate, the Guardian’s comment section was filled with left-wingers who thought the UK’s low fertility rate is a good thing! To them, humanity is no more valuable than all other things in existence. In fact, if humanity’s existence is disadvantageous to the rest of nature, they would happily see humanity go extinct.

This logic extends not just to judgments on the value of humans versus non-humans, but also to judgments on the value of actions. Consciously or not, they subscribe to the ideals of twentieth-century philosophers such as Deluze and J. L. Mackie who deem morality as something to be deconstructed or relativised. For many, no actions are objectively better than others, and no lifestyles are objectively worse than others. For the most extreme left-wingers, even truth is subjective, and so every opinion is equal.

The right, conversely, acknowledges that some things are objectively better than others – in other words, they are value realists. That some things are more beautiful than others. That diligence is better than laziness and humility is better than pride. That humans are better than non-humans. That moral value is restricted to a fairly narrow set of entities and behaviours.

This means that a good right-winger needs to champion humanity. They need to champion pro-family policies that let us have more people. They need to champion widespread and affordable housing for people to live in. They need to protect those people who are struggling to live. They need to champion growth for a more prosperous humanity, as opposed to protecting grasslands at the expense of human flourishing. And they need to champion the good life – a virtuous life lived alongside one’s family and community – because it is objectively better than the alternatives, much as humanity is objectively better to non-humanity.

The far-right, such as the aforementioned Mussolini and Marinetti, restrict value too far. To them, it is not just the case that humanity is better than non-humanity, but also that particular types of humans are much better than other humans. There is good reason to care for one’s family, friends or country more than for the rest of humanity – even John Rawls acknowledged that – but it is unconscionable to completely disregard the value that all humans have.

The crux is to restrict value far enough to be able to separate the bad or valueless from the good, but not so far as to exclude genuinely valuable things and behaviours. The left does not restrict it enough, and the far-right restricts it too far.

Freedom may seem to have disappeared from this vision. However, a crucial part of it is that we acknowledge some actions as right and others as wrong, and we want people to do more of the former and less of the latter. Yet you can only do what is right if you are free to do it. Nobody can be coerced into doing the right thing, much as nobody can be forced to volunteer. An act can only be good if it is a free choice. We should make taking the right choice as easy as possible – but we can never force it.

 

Bartek Staniszewski is the Senior Research Fellow at Bright Blue.

Share this article to the following:

Sign up here for a fortnightly roundup of our best articles.

Continue reading

Sign up for a weekly roundup of our best articles