The Special Relationship is not in jeopardy. That’s because it is based on decades of shared culture, co-operation and values between the people of America and Britain, not the latest nonsense uttered by one erratic and egotistical President. The great philosopher Karl Popper had it right: “The life of … the unknown individual man; his sorrows and joys … this is the real content of human experience down the ages … our history of the Great and the Powerful, is at best a shallow comedy.”
The Prime Minister did the right thing not allowing the US to use British bases to attack Iran initially. And he is now doing the right thing allowing the US to use those bases for defensive purposes only: to intercept Iranian missiles attacking our Middle Eastern allies.
The Iranian regime is monstrous, but it poses no imminent threat to the free world. Indeed, only last summer, Trump boasted that the surgical strikes on Iran conducted by the US and Israel, which I supported, seriously hampered Iranian nuclear and military capabilities. But there is no clear strategic objective to the current escalation — nor strategic thinking about the damaging consequences, especially on energy prices and the Middle East’s attractiveness as a place to visit, live and invest.
I say this as a liberal interventionist, who believes military action by the free world is often necessary and effective in thwarting despotic and dangerous regimes. As a child of the 90s, I remember well how NATO’s intervention in Kosovo eventually saved many Muslims from slaughter. I remember too that our inaction in — indeed, the withdrawal of UN peacekeepers from — Rwanda allowed the genocide of hundreds of thousands of Tutsis. I believe we should have surgically struck the Assad regime in the mid-2010s after it palpably and grotesquely used chemical weapons against Syrians.
I supported the invasions of Afghanistan and Iraq too, the latter now with regret considering the evidence on the existence of weapons of mass destruction was subsequently found to be flawed. But I must say that I do think the premature withdrawal of troops from both countries caused more damage than the initial invasions, leaving a vacuum that allowed ISIS and the Taliban to terrorise. Afghanistan is now the only country in the world where girls’ education is effectively banned from the age of 12, reversing decades of progress on women’s rights when we still had a military presence there. Some US troops remain stationed in Korea and Germany, over half a century after their military action concluded. If you deploy troops on the ground, expect to remain in a country for decades to maintain stability.
Today, though, Trump cannot be trusted; there is no consistency in what he says and does. Only a few months ago, Trump was threatening to invade a NATO ally. Indeed, he is now insulting NATO for not sending ships to keep the crucial oil route, the Strait of Hormuz, open. But he did not consult NATO allies before his current incursion. And NATO is a defensive alliance, there to respond to an attack on its members’ territory. He won’t see or accept it, of course, but Trump is now wanting — and seeing the value of — multilateralism. It is deeply ironic that he has requested Ukrainian assistance against Iran — through drone specialists and interceptors — after slagging off Zelensky for being disrespectful and ungrateful to the US for its support against Russian aggression.
The man is a fool. Pity the leaders of the free world who have to work with him. In the long-term, the best they can do is placate him for another three years through a combination of firmness and flattery. In the short-term, they need to unite with the Gulf states to persuade the US President that de-escalation against Iran is the best course of action.
You can read the full Bright Blue monthly bulletin here.
