Welfare policy still puts the disabled out of work

X
LinkedIn
Facebook
Lana Hempsall

Lana is the Co-Founder of Conservatives in Energy and a former Conservative Councillor.

The debate about how to reform Britain’s welfare system often focuses on the rising costs, but that risks missing the more important question of what the system is actually designed to do. The Government has repeatedly outlined their ambition to slow the growth in health-related benefits, encouraging more people back into work. Given the sharp rise in claims since the pandemic, particularly among working-age adults, that ambition is understandable. But there is a danger that the reforms fail to properly address why so many people have ended up outside the Labour market in the first place.

The uncomfortable truth is that the system, as it stands, often makes it easier to remain out of work than to try to return to it. The system’s incentive structure makes even attempting work feel like a risk. For many, particularly those managing long-term or fluctuating conditions, the choice is not between work and idleness, but between stability and uncertainty. If work is seen as something that could jeopardise financial security or lead to a loss of support that cannot easily be regained, then it is hardly surprising that people hesitate.

This is not an abstract problem for me. I began to lose my sight as a teenager and quickly found that expectations regarding what I might achieve have narrowed almost overnight. Over time, I came to realise that the biggest barrier was not simply my condition, but the way institutions, including the welfare system, responded to it. Too often, people are placed into a category that defines them by their limitations, and once they are there, it becomes difficult to move beyond it.

Many of those classed as unable to work are still capable of working. They may need adjustments, flexibility or the right environment, but that is very different from being permanently excluded from employment. The current system struggles to deal with that nuance. Instead, it tends to group together people with increasingly different circumstances, lowering expectations for those who could participate while also diluting support for those who genuinely cannot.

The scale of the issue is becoming increasingly clear. The number of people claiming health-related benefits remains historically high and mental health conditions account for a significant proportion of this increase. At the same time, employers across a wide range of sectors continue to report difficulties filling vacancies. These trends should not comfortably coexist. They point to a disconnect between people who could work and opportunities that remain unfilled, and the current system is not working to correct that disconnect.

Revisiting eligibility and assessments is necessary, but it only solves part of the problem. The harder question is what actually encourages someone to move from benefits into work when that decision carries real risk. Even with recent reforms to Personal Independence Payments (PIP) and Universal Credit, many still face uncertainty about income, support, and what happens if a job fails. Benefits, by contrast, offer predictability.

If the Government is serious about changing outcomes, it needs to address that trade-off directly. It is not enough to make work marginally more attractive on paper; instead for those who can work, it has to feel like a genuinely safer and more stable option in practice. That requires looking at how people move in and out of the system, and whether they can do so without all of their disability-related support if things go wrong.

Employers also need to be part of this solution. Flexible working and existing schemes help, but they are nowhere near enough to shift behaviour at scale. Targeted, time-limited incentives, whether to offset early-stage costs or support adjustments, could reduce the perceived risk of hiring people with health conditions and make it easier for businesses to bring people back into the workforce.

There is also a question of fairness within the system itself. As the number of claimants has grown, resources have inevitably been spread more thinly. That creates a risk that those with the most severe conditions, who are least able to work, receive less targeted support than they need. A more focused system, which better distinguishes between different levels of need and capability, would not only improve outcomes for those who can work but also strengthen support for those who cannot.

A system that focuses primarily on what people cannot do will tend to keep them there. One that is built around what people can do, and how they might be supported to do more of it, has a far better chance of helping people move forward.

The Government has at least recognised that change is needed and has begun to act. The real test now is whether it is prepared to go further and tackle the underlying incentives that shape behaviour. Welfare policy should reflect what we believe people are capable of and what we expect from the system that supports them. At its best, it should provide security while opening up opportunities. At the moment, it does not always achieve that balance, and until it does, too many people who could work will remain outside the workforce: not because they want to be, but because the alternative does not feel safe enough to attempt.

 

Original photo by CDC.

Share this article to the following:

The biggest barrier was not simply my condition, but the way institutions, including the welfare system, responded to it.
Sign up here for a fortnightly roundup of our best articles.

Continue reading

Sign up for a weekly roundup of our best articles